Publication Ethics Statement
EduSphere: Journal of Multidisciplinary Education Research is committed to maintaining integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability throughout the scholarly publication process. This statement explains the ethical responsibilities of editors, reviewers, authors, and the journal management in protecting the reliability of the academic record.
Integrity, Transparency, and Academic Responsibility
EduSphere expects every person involved in publication to act honestly, professionally, independently, and responsibly. Editorial decisions must be based on academic merit, relevance, originality, methodological quality, and compliance with the journal's policies.
Principles of Scholarly Publishing
This policy is developed with reference to recognized principles of publication ethics and transparency in scholarly publishing. The journal evaluates ethical concerns fairly and seeks to correct the publication record when reliable evidence identifies an error or violation.
Reference to recognized ethical principles does not imply membership, certification, or formal endorsement by any external organization.
Ethical Standards of the Journal
EduSphere implements the following commitments across its editorial, peer review, and publication activities.
Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions must remain independent from commercial, institutional, personal, political, or other inappropriate influence.
Fair Evaluation
Manuscripts are evaluated according to their scholarly quality and relevance without discrimination against an author's identity or institutional background.
Confidentiality
Manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial communications, and personal information must be handled confidentially.
Research Integrity
Published work must present accurate, honest, traceable, and appropriately documented research.
Transparent Correction
Significant errors and confirmed ethical violations must be addressed through appropriate corrections or other editorial notices.
Accountability
Editors, reviewers, authors, and journal managers remain accountable for fulfilling their respective ethical responsibilities.
Duties of Editors, Reviewers, and Authors
Ethical scholarly publishing requires clearly defined responsibilities for each participant in the publication process.
Editorial Responsibilities
- Evaluate manuscripts according to academic merit, originality, relevance, clarity, and compliance with journal policies.
- Protect the confidentiality of manuscripts, authors, reviewers, and editorial communications.
- Select reviewers with suitable expertise and avoid reviewers with known conflicts of interest.
- Make decisions independently and provide authors with clear information about editorial outcomes.
- Investigate credible ethical concerns without ignoring allegations because of an author's status or affiliation.
- Avoid using unpublished information for personal research or professional advantage.
- Issue corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other notices when required to protect the academic record.
Reviewer Responsibilities
- Provide objective, constructive, respectful, and evidence-based assessments.
- Accept a review assignment only when the manuscript falls within the reviewer's expertise and can be evaluated within the requested period.
- Disclose financial, professional, institutional, personal, or academic conflicts of interest.
- Treat manuscripts as confidential documents and refrain from sharing their content without editorial permission.
- Identify relevant published work that has not been properly cited when reasonably possible.
- Avoid using unpublished ideas, arguments, methods, or data obtained through peer review.
- Inform the editor when suspected plagiarism, duplication, fabrication, or another ethical problem is identified.
Author Responsibilities
- Submit original work that accurately represents the research conducted and the results obtained.
- Provide sufficient methodological information to allow readers to understand and evaluate the study.
- Cite all sources accurately and acknowledge the work of others.
- Avoid submitting substantially the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time.
- Include as authors only individuals who made meaningful scholarly contributions and accept responsibility for the work.
- Disclose funding sources, conflicts of interest, ethical approval, and other information relevant to evaluating the manuscript.
- Cooperate with editorial investigations and promptly report significant errors discovered after submission or publication.
Responsible Use of AI Tools
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot approve a manuscript, declare conflicts of interest, hold responsibility, or respond to questions concerning research integrity.
Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, citations, analysis, interpretation, confidentiality, and ethical compliance of all submitted content, including content developed with assistance from an AI tool.
- Material use of generative AI must be disclosed transparently in the manuscript or submission statement.
- The disclosure should identify the tool and explain how it was used.
- Authors must verify AI-generated statements, citations, data, and references before submission.
- Confidential manuscript data, personal information, or restricted research materials must not be entered into unauthorized AI systems.
- Undisclosed or misleading AI use may be investigated as a publication ethics concern.
Originality, Data, and Ethical Research Conduct
Submitted manuscripts must comply with accepted standards of responsible research and accurate scholarly reporting.
Originality and Plagiarism
Authors must submit original work. Text, ideas, data, images, and arguments obtained from other sources must receive appropriate acknowledgment and citation.
Data Accuracy
Data must be collected, processed, analyzed, and reported accurately. Fabrication, falsification, selective manipulation, or deliberate omission is prohibited.
Duplicate Publication
Authors must not publish or submit substantially identical findings as separate original publications without proper disclosure and justification.
Citation Integrity
Citations must be academically relevant. Citation manipulation, unnecessary self-citation, and citations added solely to influence metrics are prohibited.
Image and Document Integrity
Images, tables, transcripts, and documents must not be altered in a way that produces a misleading representation of the research evidence.
Data Availability
Authors may be asked to provide supporting data, instruments, or documentation when required to evaluate or verify a submitted study.
Human Participants, Privacy, and Consent
Research involving students, teachers, children, communities, or other human participants must respect dignity, privacy, safety, voluntary participation, and applicable ethical requirements.
Authors must obtain ethical approval when required by their institution, jurisdiction, or research context.
Informed consent must be obtained when required and clearly described in the manuscript.
Personal identities and confidential information must receive appropriate protection.
Additional safeguards must be applied when research involves children or other potentially vulnerable participants.
Conflicts of Interest and Funding
Relevant interests must be declared so that readers and editors can evaluate possible influences on the research and publication process.
Grants, employment, consultancy, honoraria, ownership, or other financial relationships related to the submitted work.
Professional competition, supervisory relationships, collaboration, or institutional responsibilities that may affect judgment.
Personal relationships or disputes that could reasonably influence an editorial, review, or authorship decision.
Funding sources and the funder's role in the design, analysis, writing, or publication decision must be disclosed.
Unacceptable Publication Practices
Plagiarism or unattributed use of another person's work.
Fabrication, falsification, or deliberate manipulation of data.
Simultaneous submission or undisclosed duplicate publication.
Gift authorship, ghost authorship, or false contribution claims.
Undisclosed conflicts of interest or misleading funding statements.
Citation manipulation or coercive citation practices.
Manipulation of peer review or submission identities.
Unauthorized disclosure or misuse of confidential materials.
Handling Allegations of Misconduct
The journal assesses credible concerns through a documented and proportionate process while respecting confidentiality and fairness.
Concern Received
The editor records the allegation and reviews the available information.
Initial Assessment
The editor determines whether the concern is credible, relevant, and supported by sufficient preliminary evidence.
Author Response
The person concerned may be asked to provide an explanation, supporting documents, or original research records.
Further Review
The journal may consult editorial members, independent experts, or the relevant institution when necessary.
Editorial Action
The journal determines an appropriate response based on the evidence, seriousness, and effect on the academic record.
Corrections and Editorial Notices
Editorial notices should explain the problem and preserve the transparency of the publication record.
Correctable Error
A correction may be issued when an error affects part of an article but does not invalidate its principal findings.
Unreliable Publication
A retraction may be issued when findings are unreliable or serious ethical violations substantially affect the publication.
Unresolved Investigation
An expression of concern may be published when serious questions remain unresolved while an investigation continues.
Exceptional Circumstances
Removal is considered only in exceptional situations involving legal, safety, privacy, or similarly serious concerns.
Appealing a Decision
Authors may submit a reasoned appeal when they believe an editorial decision resulted from a significant factual misunderstanding, procedural problem, or material error.
- The appeal must address the decision and supporting reasons.
- Disagreement alone does not guarantee reconsideration.
- The appeal should remain respectful and evidence-based.
- The final decision rests with the authorized editor.
Submitting an Ethical Concern
Complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, conflicts, published content, or suspected misconduct should include sufficient details and supporting information.
- Identify the manuscript or article concerned.
- Explain the ethical or procedural issue clearly.
- Provide supporting evidence when available.
- Avoid unsupported, abusive, or defamatory allegations.
Publication Ethics Contact
Ethical concerns, complaints, corrections, and appeals may be submitted to the editorial office. Reports should include the reporter's contact information, the relevant manuscript or article details, a clear explanation, and supporting evidence when available.