Screening for Plagiarism

ORIGINALITY · SIMILARITY · ACADEMIC INTEGRITY

Screening for Plagiarism

Journal of Science, Mathematics and Educational Innovation considers originality and proper academic attribution essential elements of responsible scholarly publishing.

✓
Editorial Quality Control Similarity Screening Process
JSMEI Originality
Matters
Screen · Review · Verify
SP
SCREENING POLICY

Protecting Academic Originality

Manuscript similarity screening is used as part of the editorial assessment process to help identify text overlap, unattributed material, duplicate content, and other potential originality concerns.

A similarity percentage alone does not automatically establish plagiarism. Editorial assessment should consider the source, context, citation, quotation, type of overlap, and overall structure of the manuscript.

SCREENING INFORMATION

Originality Screening Overview

Pre-Publication Check
SCREENING TOOL

SCREENING SOFTWARE

The journal uses an originality or similarity screening system according to its editorial policy.

SIMILARITY POLICY Editorial Reference
XX% MAXIMUM / POLICY THRESHOLD

Replace this value with the official JSMEI similarity threshold once the journal policy has been finalized.

IMPORTANT Similarity ≠ Plagiarism
EDITORIAL INTERPRETATION

Similarity Reports Require Academic Judgment

Similarity reports identify textual overlap with existing sources. Editors should evaluate whether the overlap is appropriately quoted, cited, technically unavoidable, methodologically standard, or potentially problematic.

SCREENING WORKFLOW

How Manuscript Similarity Is Reviewed

5 Stages
01
SUBMISSIONStage 01

Manuscript Received

A submitted manuscript enters the journal's editorial assessment process.

03
ASSESSMENTStage 03

Editorial Review of Results

Editors evaluate the similarity report by considering the sources and context of identified text overlap.

04
ACTIONStage 04

Author Clarification or Revision

Where appropriate, authors may be asked to revise problematic text, improve attribution, or provide clarification.

05
DECISIONStage 05

Editorial Determination

The manuscript proceeds, is returned for revision, or may receive another editorial decision depending on the findings.

EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT

What Editors Examine

01
SOURCE

Source of Similarity

Whether the matching text originates from published research, websites, repositories, or other material.

02
CITATION

Proper Attribution

Whether matching material is appropriately cited, referenced, or quoted.

03
CONTEXT

Nature of Overlap

Whether overlap occurs in standard terminology, methods, definitions, or substantive scholarly content.

04
EXTENT

Amount of Similarity

The overall level and distribution of matching material across the manuscript.

05
ORIGINALITY

Scholarly Contribution

Whether the manuscript demonstrates sufficient originality in its argument, analysis, and contribution.

06
DUPLICATION

Previous Publication

Whether substantial material overlaps with the author's own previously published work without appropriate disclosure.

SCREENING OUTCOMES

Possible Editorial Responses

01
RESULT

Proceed

No significant originality concern is identified during editorial assessment.

Continue Editorial Process
02
RESULT

Revision Required

Authors may be asked to revise text, improve citation, or address identified similarity concerns.

Return to Author
03
RESULT

Further Assessment

Significant concerns may require additional editorial clarification or integrity assessment.

Editorial Review
04
RESULT

Editorial Rejection

A manuscript may be rejected where serious originality or publication integrity problems are identified.

Editorial Decision
AUTHOR RESPONSIBILITY

Before Submitting a Manuscript

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts are original, properly referenced, accurately quoted, and do not contain inappropriate duplication of previously published material.

✓Use proper citations
✓Quote sources correctly
✓Avoid unattributed copying
✓Disclose related publications
✓
ORIGINALITY & PUBLICATION INTEGRITY

Similarity Screening Supports Editorial Judgment

JSMEI uses originality assessment to support responsible scholarly publishing while ensuring that similarity findings are interpreted in their proper academic context.

JSMEI